Already have an account?Sign In

3 Things to Consider If You Want to Get Back Together After a Breakup

Last modified: January 6, 2020 Avatar for Adrienne ThorneBy Adrienne Thorne
3 Things to Consider If You Want to Get Back Together After a Breakup

It’s never easy to know what to do with yourself after a breakup.

You may be confused as to why your relationship ended. Or maybe you want to start the healing process, but don’t know where to begin. You’re sorting through negative emotions, and may find yourself reaching for self-help books to sort things out.

You’re not alone if a relationship breakup leaves you reeling.

Recently, I saw a conversation in the Catholic Dating section of Reddit about emotional pain and relationship discernment. A man shared about how he went on two dates with a woman and he felt strongly attracted to her.

But despite his hopes for their future together, she told him that she didn’t think a romantic relationship was in their future.

A few short months later, he ran into this woman again. They talked briefly, and now he can’t stop thinking about her.

Should he try reaching out and see if she’s interested in trying again?

There’s no denying that breakups suck.

But the advice other Catholics gave on Reddit can give anyone grieving a breakup some good insight into how to look at future prospects with a person who ended a relationship.

1. This breakup was probably for a reason


If you find yourself feeling excited about someone who previously ended things with you, think back to that unpleasant moment when they ended it. What emotions did you experience in that situation?

One Reddit user tells the original poster that, “the best advice is not to try to start up a relationship again since she already told you that she didn’t see it going anywhere.”

The original poster mentions that, despite how enamored he felt with this woman originally, she didn’t seem to feel the same way about him. She told him directly that she “didn’t see the relationship going anywhere.”

A statement like this doesn’t leave a lot of room for misinterpretation.

If nothing dramatic has changed in your life or their life, it’s probably safe to assume that the reasons they didn’t purse an intimate relationship with you are still valid, and that their feelings haven’t changed.

2. Are you over-romanticizing things?

broken hearted man

The poster does admit from the get-go that he might be inadvertently over-romanticizing the situation in his mind:

“Not helping is the fact that I’ve been reading a Catholic romance novel… in which the relationship didn’t get off to a good start and they disconnected for a few months, but over time they reconnected and things got better. I know it’s fiction, but it’s hard not to imagine the same happening for me.”

Whether you happen to be reading a romance novel or not, it’s easy to fall into the trap of imagining happy but unlikely scenarios for your yourself, especially if you’re in the middle of the grieving process surrounding a painful breakup.

One Reddit user cautions him about this: “Those of us who’ve been ‘in love’ before, but heartbroken, know first hand that it seems like everything is right with someone and if this or if that, then all things will be happy. That’s just not the way it works…

“You can feel completely ‘yes’ for someone and they will feel ‘no’ for you, and it’s like quicksand. The more you think about this confusion, the more it mires you, and it traps you in fantasies and dreams. It traps you in ‘the ifs’. It gives you just enough hope to keep yourself mired.”

The reality is that unlikely romantic scenarios can indeed happen to us in real life. But we can’t force them to happen to us. Wishing for things to go a certain way won’t make them go that way.

3. You deserve someone who is excited about you

broken hearted woman

The original poster describes the time he ran into this woman again in this way:

“I approached her and we talked for a bit. She was friendly and introduced me to her younger sister whom she was with, but didn’t seem super eager to talk.”

There’s nothing in this description that should be a basis for romantic hope with this woman.

She didn’t flirt with him and didn’t even seem excited to have run into him. She seems to have merely been acting politely toward him.

A couple of other Reddit users give him some cold, hard truth in their advice, regarding her apparent lack of interest and his hope for another date with her:

“No. Full stop. The interest is too obviously 100% unilateral.”


But despite the harshness of this response, there’s quite a bit of truth here.

Another user responds similarly: “Hard no. Get this one out of your head. She seems to be at a completely different place in her life.”

Again, a little harsh but still true. This poster goes on to say:

“Dwelling on someone like this blocks you from thinking about someone else who’ll lead somewhere. You deserve to think about someone who thinks about you, and I don’t get that feeling whatsoever from this one. I think she wants to be nice and polite, but she isn’t interested.”

This point is important to consider. By allowing yourself to dwell on possibilities with someone who is almost certainly not interested in a relationship with you, you can become distracted from others with whom there is real potential.

Another Reddit user sums this point up nicely: “Move on, God has a different girl in mind for you that you will feel the same way for x 1000 and she will feel it back.”

When you find your heart wandering toward hopes for a relationship with someone who has already ended things with you in the past, do your best to reign in your heart.

You deserve much more than someone who feels only half-hearted interest toward you. You deserve someone who is excited about the possibility of a future with you.

Ready to start dating after a breakup?

If you’re ready to give dating a try again, we’re here to help. Catholic Singles is a relationship expert when it comes to online dating. After all, we’ve been at this since 1997.

Online dating can help you expand your dating pool, and creating an online dating profile could be the first step towards a new long-term relationship. If you’re ready to start dating, we can help you create a dating profile today!

Avatar for Adrienne Thorne

Adrienne Thorne is a Catholic wife, mother, screenwriter, and blogger, as well as author of the Catholic YA romance novel SYDNEY AND CALVIN HAVE A BABY. She blogs about TV and Movies from Catholic perspective at Thorne in the Flesh: A Faithful Catholic's Guide to Netflix, Hulu, and More.

    Jay Atienza
    14 Jan 2020

    I’m sorry, but your article seems pointless. The title of the article is “3 Things to Consider If You Want to Get Back Together After a Breakup”. The article content does not give any professional relationship advice on how to actually deal with the issue you have mentioned as the title.

    First of all, the man who was described had only been on two dates. That can hardly be called a serious relationship. It’s the very early stages. Even before things get serious. The two people meeting for the first time have to establish chemistry and agree to move forward to a steady relationship. If they were actually in an exclusive serious relationship after numerous dates and they could not go any further. That would be considered a “break-up” with serious heartbreak and issues to deal with.

    The guy you are referencing just seems to be infatuated and he was rejected by a girl who didn’t feel the same chemistry. Best advice is to either cut his losses and try with another girl or try again if he feels there’s another chance. But, this isn’t close to being a “break-up”. It was never serious to begin with and he needs to be less emotional about being rejected.

    Next thing, your article only recites the comments provided by other people on a reddit page. These are not relationship experts. What weight do they have to give on “Things to consider after a break”?

    I would appreciate reading real advice by experts on an actual example that makes sense.

    Please consider this when writing another article. I felt strong enough to write back as a critique to help you. Nothing personal.

    Thanks for reading.

    Euphrates Zigbuo
    16 Jan 2020

    Nice advice it enlightens my mind

Leave A Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *